All stories by ELISABETH VINCENTELLI on BroadwayStars

Wednesday, July 23, 2014

Leight’s ‘Summer Shorts’ fall flat by Elisabeth Vincentelli

Warren Leight found a nifty way to sum up 20 years’ worth of Knicks agony: In “Sec. 310, Row D, Seats 5 and 6,” the Tony-winning writer of “Side Man”...

SOURCE: The New York Post at 07:03PM

5 Hollywood hits that fizzled on (and off) Broadway by Elisabeth Vincentelli

Stories that pop on the big screen can fizzle when they hit the stage. For every hit like “Once” there are a dozen misfires like “Bullets Over Broadway,” the latest...

SOURCE: The New York Post at 02:08PM
Thursday, July 17, 2014

‘Pump Boys and Dinettes’ showcases a charming revival by Elisabeth Vincentelli

Encores! Off-Center has done a bang-up job reviving obscurish off-Broadway musicals, some of which, on the strength of these productions, later made it to Broadway. “Pump Boys and Dinettes…

SOURCE: The New York Post at 06:01PM
Wednesday, July 2, 2014

Randy Newman revives his ‘Faust’ musical for one night only by Elisabeth Vincentelli

Randy Newman’s only musical, “Faust,” is an odd bird: It’s never been staged in New York, yet it’s spawned a couple of famous-ish songs. You may have heard Bonnie Raitt’s...

SOURCE: The New York Post at 03:45PM
Monday, June 30, 2014

Scheuer’s ‘The Lion’ too one-sided to be interesting by Elisabeth Vincentelli

No matter what Benjamin Scheuer talks or sings about in his solo musical, “The Lion,” he sticks to a monotone that’s polite at best, bland at worst. Which is pretty...

SOURCE: The New York Post at 07:20PM
Thursday, June 26, 2014

Lin-Manuel Miranda and Karen Olivo revive ‘tick, tick…BOOM!’ by Elisabeth Vincentelli

Jonathan Larson’s legacy usually boils down to “Rent.” But the Encores! Off-Center series is making a strong case for his lesser-known “tick, tick…BOOM!” with a high-energy p…

SOURCE: The New York Post at 10:31PM

Cartoonish ‘Muscles in Our Toes’ makes little sense on stage by Elisabeth Vincentelli

The thing with reunions is that they always boil down to the same big ideas: Nobody’s the way they used to be, friendship is treacherous, and you can’t go home...

SOURCE: The New York Post at 10:01PM
Monday, June 23, 2014

Mikhail Baryshnikov, Willem Dafoe are live-action Itchy and Scratchy in ‘The Old Woman’ by Elisabeth Vincentelli

‘The Old Woman” is pretty much a live-action version of “The Itchy & Scratchy Show” starring Mikhail Baryshnikov and Willem Dafoe. This new theatrical piece has all the vaudevill…

SOURCE: The New York Post at 04:33PM
Thursday, June 19, 2014

‘Holler!’ 2-Pac musical is an old-school Broadway ride by Elisabeth Vincentelli

Rap on Broadway? Purists, relax — “Holler If Ya Hear Me,” the Tupac Shakur musical that opened Thursday night, is endearingly traditional. Yes, there’s gangsta anger and lots of prof…

SOURCE: The New York Post at 10:56PM

Jane Lynch is her usual funny self in convincing cabaret debut by Elisabeth Vincentelli

Th3 strapping Jane Lynch came up short in only one way Wednesday night: Her cabaret debut — “my maiden voyage,” she quipped — ended too soon. Even with two encores,...

SOURCE: The New York Post at 04:53PM
Wednesday, June 18, 2014

9 ‘Harry Potter’ stars who leapt from the screen to the stage by Elisabeth Vincentelli

No wonder more and more members of the casts of the eight “Harry Potter” films are turning up onstage: After all, most of Hogwarts’ teaching staff seems to have been...

SOURCE: The New York Post at 10:36AM

Kazan makes a difference in ‘When We Were Young’ by Elisabeth Vincentelli

Two generations face off in off-Broadway’s “When We Were Young and Unafraid.” The older, wiser woman is Agnes (Cherry Jones), a former military nurse who runs a B&B that doubles...

SOURCE: The New York Post at 05:06AM
Tuesday, June 17, 2014

‘Harry Potter’ alum Rupert Grint heading to Broadway by Elisabeth Vincentelli

Ron Weasley’s coming to Broadway! Rupert Grint — the ginger-haired Hogwarts kid from all eight Harry Potter movies — will make his New York stage debut in the revival of...

SOURCE: The New York Post at 04:51PM

Few sparks in ‘Much Ado About Nothing’ by Elisabeth Vincentelli

Shakespeare’s “Much Ado About Nothing” is the original romantic comedy — its leads are very vocal about how much they can’t stand each other. In other words, they’re destined…

SOURCE: The New York Post at 05:39AM
Monday, June 16, 2014

Akhtar’s follow-up to ‘Disgraced’ is didactic and predictable by Elisabeth Vincentelli

A couple of years ago, Ayad Akhtar won the Pulitzer Prize for “Disgraced” — which is headed to Broadway this fall, with “How I Met Your Mother” star Josh Radnor....

SOURCE: The New York Post at 10:06PM
Wednesday, June 11, 2014

Earnest ‘Fly by Night’ will enchant audiences by Elisabeth Vincentelli

The new musical “Fly by Night” is off-Broadway’s answer to “The Fault in Our Stars” — earnest, enthusiastic and possibly requiring a tissue or two by the end. Romance doesn’t...

SOURCE: The New York Post at 08:06PM

Provocative ‘New Girl’ spotlights unusual mother-son duo by Elisabeth Vincentelli

In a shocker of an opening scene, Daniel takes a large knife from the kitchen and prepares to slice off his ear. Blackout. It’s a heart-stopping way to begin a...

SOURCE: The New York Post at 05:30PM
Tuesday, June 10, 2014

Greta Gerwig brings her sunny charm to ‘The Village Bike’ by Elisabeth Vincentelli

Greta Gerwig could have found a much easier vehicle than “The Village Bike.” But no, the blond star of “Frances Ha” and other indie films picked a doozy of a...

SOURCE: The New York Post at 10:20PM
Saturday, June 7, 2014

How 3 Tony best actress nominees get into their roles by Elisabeth Vincentelli

Mary Bridget Davies Stars as: Janis Joplin in “A Night with Janis Joplin” “I based my dressing room on [photos from Janis’ life]: tapestries, candles, 1930s lamps, two of my...

SOURCE: The New York Post at 01:05PM
Friday, June 6, 2014

Cori Thomas’ sweet Harlem-set comedy slacks off but has winning touches by Elisabeth Vincentelli

Two epically awkward dates make a satisfying finale to the off-Broadway comedy “When January Feels Like Summer” — they’re a long time coming, though. Playwright Cori Thomas enjoys he…

SOURCE: The New York Post at 07:01PM

Over-the-top Macbeth full of sound, fury and wow by Elisabeth Vincentelli

For his New York stage debut, Kenneth Branagh could have gotten away with anything. A solo reading of takeout menus? It’s a hit! Instead, the Shakespeare expert brought over a...

SOURCE: The New York Post at 03:37AM
Thursday, June 5, 2014

Who should and who will win at Sunday’s Tony Awards by Elisabeth Vincentelli

Forget about California Chrome and the Triple Crown: For many New Yorkers, the handicapping race this week is all about the Tonys. Ahead of Sunday’s telecast, we balance out who...

SOURCE: The New York Post at 11:00AM
Wednesday, June 4, 2014

Catch up with the best show tunes before the Tony Awards by Elisabeth Vincentelli

Back in the day, Broadway songs often became million-selling hits that wormed their way into America’s subconsciousness (remember “Tonight,” from “West Side Story”?) Now this happe…

SOURCE: The New York Post at 04:48PM
Tuesday, June 3, 2014

Jim Dale says a lot but reveals little in one-man show by Elisabeth Vincentelli

Either Jim Dale has led an uneventful life, or he’s keeping the juicy stuff to himself. Either way, his new autobiographical show, “Just Jim Dale,” is easygoing but not especially...

SOURCE: The New York Post at 10:55PM
Monday, June 2, 2014

Michael Shannon does some heavy lifting in ‘The Killer’ by Elisabeth Vincentelli

You’d expect Michael Shannon to play the title role in “The Killer.” Broody and intense, he’s best known for tortured, often villainous characters — think General Zod in “Man…

SOURCE: The New York Post at 05:03AM
Friday, May 30, 2014

Rand musical more pain than ‘Anthem’ by Elisabeth Vincentelli

Once in a blue moon comes a show so laughably bad, it’s almost enjoyable — almost. Enter “The Anthem.” Loosely based on Ayn Rand’s 1938 sci-fi novella “Anthem,” this inept...

SOURCE: The New York Post at 06:38AM
Friday, May 23, 2014

Fast-food comedy gets the McJob done by Elisabeth Vincentelli

There are no costumed dudes battling evil in “American Hero” — just subs and hoagies. Though, come to think of it, the three leads in Bess Wohl’s bittersweet, terrifically acted...

SOURCE: The New York Post at 06:05AM
Thursday, May 22, 2014

Shakespeare’s reign over NY stages continues by Elisabeth Vincentelli

Once the temperature rises, the entire city becomes Shakespeare Central. The Bard is as inevitable as a superhero movie on Memorial Day weekend — and most of the productions are...

SOURCE: The New York Post at 01:09AM
Wednesday, May 21, 2014

McDormand, Roche bring ‘Early Shaker Spirituals’ to life by Elisabeth Vincentelli

If the Amish are famous for their beards and buggies, the Shakers are reputed for their elegant, minimalist furniture. But that second religious group — its formal name is the...

SOURCE: The New York Post at 05:41PM
Friday, May 9, 2014

‘The Few’ keeps its characters living in the past by Elisabeth Vincentelli

Trucking is a great subject for a play — “breaker breaker,” colorful personalities, the lure of the road and all that. Yet “The Few” is strangely uninvolving, its intriguing potent…

SOURCE: The New York Post at 10:00PM
Thursday, May 8, 2014

Lovely songs — and penguins — save dated musical’s plot by Elisabeth Vincentelli

Encores! has presented plenty of odd ducks in the past two decades, but it’s still hard to beat “Irma la Douce” and its ballet for bearded penguins. Marguerite Monnot’s delightful...

SOURCE: The New York Post at 02:05PM