The Outsiders welcomed new cast members beginning on Tuesday, March 17 at the Jacobs Theatre. BroadwayWorld was there to capture the cast taking their first bows. Check out photos below! The cast is led by Noah Pacht as "Ponyboy Curtis," Caleb Mathura as "Johnny Cade," SeQuoiia as "Dallas Winston," Dan Berry as "Darrel Curtis," Sutton James Kaylor as "Sodapop Curtis," Emma Pittman as "Cherry Valance," Daryl Tofa a…
SOURCE: BroadwayWorld at 09:54AM on March 18, 2026