The strike by IATSE Local One, otherwise known as Broadway's stagehands, is not going well for either side. But Local One is losing the PR war.
The League of American Theatres and Producers (The League) has put out two press releases (The Facts About The Stagehands Strike and Update From Charlotte St. Martin Regarding Strike By Local One, IATSE Stagehands) while Local One has put out a flier (Local One Strike Flier)
Lets look at what Local One is claiming:
We keep hearing this stat, but Local One has not backed it up with an explanation. Who is taking a pay cut? Please be specific. Which jobs are being eliminated? Is there a safety issue here or is it totally fiscal?
Yes, Broadway is a billon dollar a year industry. But whether or not is has been more profitable than ever is disputable. There is a very drastic difference between "gross" and profit. How many shows opened on Broadway last year? How many were profitable? It costs an average of $20,800,000 per year to run a Broadway show (@$400K/week, which is low, especially for a few larger shows which cost upwards of $600K/week to run.) When matched against weekly grosses, there are few shows actually making a profit.
No one expects ticket prices to go down, but making the statement that producers pocket the difference is not only irresponsible, possibly libel, but also naive with respect to the budgetary process and the way in which producers make money.
The League is claiming:
I believe that The League is referring to a show that is already running and not to the load-in/load-out. But those are damning numbers for Local One. The majority of actors on Broadway are under a chorus contract that is about 1/2 the salary of that. (source: Actor's Equity website.)
Is The League correct in their assertion that the Head Electrician is prohibited from doing more than 10 minutes of work each show? Please chime in Local One or others to explain.
When we are loading in a new show, we must hire an entire stagehand crew all day, every day, even when they are not needed. We end up paying many stagehands who are not needed, and who do nothing.
These two items were separate in The League press release, but are related. One dropped piano is a lot more expensive to a Producer than the cost of a few extra hands per day. But Local One should also provide a solution for obvious areas of cost savings by matching salary levels with skill levels.
Is this really true? What is the Local One response to this?
Regardless of who is right or wrong here, Local One is losing the PR war. Parents (nee: ticket buyer) with children crying outside of Grinch are not believing that the $150K/year picketers are being treated unfairly by The League. Actors, Musicians, Ushers, Box Office, Production Office and the rest who are not collecting paychecks cannot afford to support a strike over fiscal-only issues. Very few, if any of those mentioned, are making close to what Local One members make.
If there is a different Local One message that is not making it undistorted through the media, please send it to me and I will print it unedited. If not, it is time to get back to work.
Monday, November 12, 2007 | Item LinkIf you would like to contact us, you can email us at feedback@
broadwaystars.com